Smash Burger Press and Why a Flat Bottom Is the Only Thing That Matters
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Some links may earn us a commission at no extra cost to you.
A smash burger is a Maillard reaction problem. You are trying to get the greatest possible area of beef in hard contact with the hottest possible metal for the first thirty seconds, because that contact is where the brown crust comes from. Everything follows from that. The face of the press has to be genuinely flat, because any groove is an area of the patty not touching the pan. It has to be wider than the patty you want. And you press once, straight away, then never again, since pressing a cooked burger just wrings the juice out of it. One product in this search is sold as a smash burger press with a grooved bottom for grill marks, which is a bacon press wearing the wrong label, and it carries the lowest rating here. So I score these on contact area.
Top picks
Cuisinart CISB-111 Cast Iron Burger Press — Best overall
- HEAVY-DUTY CAST IRON: 6.5" cast iron burger press ensures even pressure, creating juicy, flavorful smashed burgers every time.
- PERFECT SMASH BURGER CRUST: Flat edge helps achieve crispy, caramelized edges for that classic smash burger taste.
- VERSATILE SMASHING: Ideal for use on griddles, skillets, and grills, making it perfect for both indoor cooking and outdoor cookouts.
Why it wins: A flat 6.5 inch cast iron face with more than forty thousand ratings behind it, which is several times the review base of anything else in this search. That diameter is the useful one: wide enough to take a two ounce ball out to a proper thin patty without the edge of the press cutting a ridge into it.
Pros
- By far the largest review base in the category
- 6.5 inches is the right diameter for a standard smashed patty
- Cast iron mass does the work so you are not leaning on it
- Genuinely flat face with no grooves or pattern
Cons
- Cast iron needs drying immediately and will rust if left wet
- Meat sticks without a square of parchment between press and patty
- Heavier to handle than the stainless options
- Wooden handle rules out putting it in the dishwasher
Social proof: See rating and reviews on Amazon.
Trade-offs and who should skip: The one most people have bought, for good reason. Skip it if you will not hand dry it. Skip it if you want something dishwasher safe.
Scores: Performance 5/5 | Contact area 5/5 | Ease of use 4/5 | Value 4/5
Firsgrill Round and Rectangle Cast Iron Set — Best for a griddle
- BURGERS – Perfect for smash burgers with beautiful grill marks BACON – Keeps strips flat and cooks evenly STEAKS – Helps sear and cook evenly THIN MEATS – Works great on any flat-top griddle or outdoor grill.
- FOOD-GRADE CAST IRON & SAFETY FIRST Crafted from premium cast iron with a BPA-free, heat-resistant handle, this 7.1-inch round press is built for high-heat performance without compromising safety. Fully compliant materials ensure no harmful chemicals leach into your food—so you can smash with confidence whether you're cooking for kids or a crowd.
- FULL-COVERAGE DESIGN FOR JUICY, CRISP EDGES Oversized at 7.08 inches to fully cover 1/3 to 1/2 lb patties, this press delivers even contact for that perfect smash every time. No more uneven edges or undercooked spots—just consistently crispy, caramelized crusts that lock in juices, ideal for gourmet burgers, breakfast sausage patties, or seared vegetables.
Why it wins: A 7 inch round and a rectangular press together, which covers the two jobs a flat top actually asks for: smashing patties and holding bacon, sausage or a sandwich flat across a long surface. The rectangle is the piece people wish they had bought once they own a griddle.
Pros
- Two shapes, so one purchase covers patties and long items
- 7 inches is the widest round face here
- Strong rating on a large review base
- Flat bottoms on both pieces rather than grooved
Cons
- Two cast iron pieces to season, dry and store
- Costs more than a single press
- Overkill for anyone cooking in a skillet
- Heavy enough to be awkward for smaller hands
Social proof: See rating and reviews on Amazon.
Trade-offs and who should skip: The right kit if you own a flat top. Skip it if you only cook in a frying pan. Skip it if storage space is short.
Scores: Performance 5/5 | Contact area 5/5 | Ease of use 3/5 | Value 4/5
HULISEN Stainless Steel Burger Press — Best value
- High Quality Stainless Steel: The burger press made of Brushed Stainless Steel including grip handle, stain resistant and rustproof. The round grip handle adopt laser welding technology, which will not become loose over time, and it can stay firm for a long time
- Reduce Cooking Time: Efficient cooking, you can exerting pressure to make food complete cooking faster while adding a unique flavor, press out the grease for healthy cooking, It's much easier to use than griddle spatula or forming by hand
- Smooth & Flat Surface: A flat and smooth bottom of the smashed burger press can help you get a burger of uniform thickness. Smooth, brushed stainless steel feature not-stick, easy to clean and dishwasher safe
Why it wins: A 6.2 inch stainless face costing less than anything else here, and stainless solves the two cast iron annoyances at once: it goes in the dishwasher and it will not rust if you leave it on the drainer. For a tool that spends thirty seconds in contact with food, the thermal properties of cast iron matter less than people assume.
Pros
- Dishwasher safe, unlike everything with a wooden handle
- No seasoning and no rust risk
- Cheapest way to a proper flat press
- Thousands of ratings at a high average
Cons
- Lighter than cast iron, so you supply more of the force yourself
- Handle transmits heat faster than a wooden one
- Thin stainless can flex if you lean on it hard
Social proof: See rating and reviews on Amazon.
Trade-offs and who should skip: Does the job for a fraction of the money. Skip it if you want the press to do the pushing. Skip it if a bare metal handle worries you.
Scores: Performance 4/5 | Contact area 5/5 | Ease of use 5/5 | Value 5/5
Sasquash Stainless Steel Smash Press — Best built
- Flat Handle Control: The extra-wide flat handle creates a steadier pressing angle and more direct downward force, so you can flatten ground beef with a firm and comfortable grip. That added leverage helps form thinner patties with better pan contact on griddles, cast iron pans, and skillets, making it easier to build crisp-edged smash burgers, seared sandwiches, bacon, and other fast family meals with more consistency from batch to batch on busy nights at home
- One Piece Welded Strength: Built with a welded one piece frame and thick 2 mm stainless steel, this smashed burger press is made for repeated pressing without the flex and wobble that can interrupt your smash. The rigid round surface stays stable as you press, helping you cook with a smoother rhythm whether you are making a single dinner burger, prepping several patties for family night, or working through a full flat top session where steady pressure matters from the first smash to the last
- Smooth Round Press Surface: The smooth 6 inch bottom gives you broad, even contact across the patty, which helps create a uniform shape and makes the press easier to lift after the smash. Add a quick twist, then lift cleanly and move to the next burger. That simple motion helps keep ground beef from bunching in the center, supports better crust contact on the cook surface, and gives home cooks an easier way to turn loose meat into thin patties with the seared edges smash burger fans look for
Why it wins: Welded one-piece stainless with a flat bar handle, which removes the failure point every other design shares: a handle bolted or screwed into the plate that eventually works loose. There is nothing here to season, nothing to unscrew and nothing to snap.
Pros
- Welded construction with no fastener to loosen
- Flat handle gives you leverage directly over the centre
- Stainless throughout, so it is dishwasher safe
Cons
- Most expensive press on this page
- 6 inches is slightly narrower than the cast iron options
- All-metal handle gets hot on a griddle
- Plain looking next to the wooden-handled presses
Social proof: See rating and reviews on Amazon.
Trade-offs and who should skip: Buy once. Skip it if you want the widest face. Skip it if you would rather spend the money on beef.
Scores: Performance 4/5 | Contact area 4/5 | Ease of use 4/5 | Value 3/5
Amazon Basics Cast Iron Press — Grooved, and mislabelled
- WHAT'S INCLUDED: 1 round cast iron burger press for creating uniformly shaped patties; ideal as a smash burger press for consistent results
- HEAVY-DUTY CONSTRUCTION: Made of durable cast iron with wooden handle for comfortable grip during use on grills, griddles, and skillets
- GRILL MARKS: Grooved bottom creates delicious grill marks on burgers, bacon, steaks, and sandwiches for enhanced presentation
Why it wins: It is here to make the point. The listing calls it a smash burger press and then describes a grooved bottom for grill marks, and those two things are in direct conflict: grooves lift part of the patty away from the pan, so you get stripes of crust and gaps between them instead of the unbroken brown sheet that makes a smash burger worth making. It has the lowest rating in this search.
Pros
- Perfectly good bacon press, which is what a grooved bottom is for
- Cast iron with a comfortable wooden handle
- 6.8 inches is a generous diameter
- Cheap for cast iron
Cons
- Grooved face defeats the purpose of smashing
- Lowest rating of the five here
- Sold under a smash burger heading it does not fit
- Grooves trap fat and are harder to wipe clean
Social proof: See rating and reviews on Amazon.
Trade-offs and who should skip: Right tool, wrong aisle. Skip it if you want smash burgers. Skip it if you already own a bacon press.
Scores: Performance 3/5 | Contact area 1/5 | Ease of use 4/5 | Value 3/5
Quick compare
- Best overall: Cuisinart 6.5 inch, needs drying
- For a griddle: Firsgrill round and rectangle, two pieces to look after
- Best value: HULISEN stainless, lighter so you press harder
- Best built: Sasquash welded, costs the most
- Grooved: Amazon Basics, wrong face for the job
Two things that will improve your burgers more than any of these. Use a square of parchment or a patty paper between the press and the meat, because beef welds itself to hot metal and the tool that lifts half your patty off the pan has ruined it whatever it cost. And get the pan properly hot before anything touches it: the crust comes from the temperature of the surface, not from how hard you push, so a screaming hot skillet with a cheap press beats a warm one with an expensive press every time. If you are pressing more than once, you are squeezing out the fat that was going to make it taste good.
As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases.